Staten Island offers a unique proposition within New York City: the space and feel of suburban living combined with the value of an NYC property. For homeowners, renovations here are focused on creating dream homes for growing families, maximizing indoor-outdoor living, and making smart, value-driven investments.
This guide provides a detailed breakdown of 2025 renovation costs specifically for the Staten Island market. We'll cover the most popular projects, from kitchen expansions to backyard transformations, that make the borough such a desirable place to live. For a personalized estimate for your home, use our official NYC Renovation Cost Calculator.
Average Renovation Costs in Staten Island by Project Type
Staten Island offers the best value for construction costs in all of New York City. Easier logistics, more space to work, and a competitive local market allow homeowners to undertake larger, more ambitious projects for their budget.
| Project Type | Typical Cost Range (Full Gut) | What It Includes in a Staten Island Context |
|---|---|---|
Kitchen Renovation | $50,000 - $115,000+ | Often large, open-concept kitchens that serve as the hub of the home. Projects frequently include expanding into a dining area or adding a small extension for an eat-in space. |
Full Home Renovation | $250 - $500+ / sq ft | A complete renovation of a single-family detached home, often including new siding, roofing, and windows in addition to a full interior overhaul. |
Home Addition | $400 - $750 / sq ft | One of the most popular projects in the borough. Adding a second story or a large rear extension to create more bedrooms, a primary suite, or a great room for the family. |
Basement & Outdoor Living | $75,000 - $160,000+ | Finishing a basement to create a rec room or home theater, often combined with creating a backyard oasis with a new deck, patio, and outdoor kitchen. |
Staten Island Renovation Costs by Area
While known for its suburban feel, Staten Island's neighborhoods have distinct characteristics that influence renovation styles and costs.
| Area Type | Average Cost Per Sq Ft (Gut) | Example Neighborhoods | Key Cost Factors |
|---|---|---|---|
North Shore Historic Districts | $300 - $550 / sq ft | St. George, New Brighton, Stapleton | Renovating historic Victorian and Colonial homes may require adherence to preservation standards, similar to other NYC landmarked areas. |
Mid-Island Residential | $275 - $500 / sq ft | Todt Hill, Emerson Hill, Grasmere | A mix of large, high-end custom homes and classic suburban properties. Focus on luxury finishes and expansive additions. |
South Shore Suburban | $250 - $475 / sq ft | Annadale, Huguenot, Tottenville | Newer housing stock and spacious lots provide a blank canvas for family-focused renovations and modernizations with excellent value. |
Detailed Component Guides
Explore detailed cost breakdowns for specific Staten Island renovation projects:
The "Staten Island Advantage": Space, Value, and Lifestyle
Renovating in Staten Island offers a unique set of benefits that are simply not possible in the denser boroughs.
Space to Grow
This is the biggest advantage. Larger lots mean that significant home additions—whether a second story or a multi-room rear extension—are not just possible, but popular. You can fundamentally change the size and layout of your home.
The Best Value in NYC
Your renovation budget goes further in Staten Island than anywhere else in the five boroughs. Lower logistical costs and a competitive labor market mean you can afford higher-quality materials and more extensive work.
Indoor-Outdoor Living
Staten Island is the only borough where the backyard is a true centerpiece of the home. Renovations often include creating a seamless flow from interior to exterior with large decks, patios, outdoor kitchens, and pool houses.
Fewer Logistical Headaches
Renovating a detached single-family home with a private driveway is infinitely simpler than a co-op in Manhattan. No co-op boards, no service elevators, and far fewer restrictions on work hours.
Ready to Build Your Forever Home in Staten Island?
Staten Island provides the perfect setting to create a spacious, modern home tailored to your family's lifestyle. It's a place where you can invest in your property with confidence, knowing you are building lasting value and a wonderful quality of life.
Let's explore the possibilities for your home.